Born in Portsmouth, Ohio, known to friends as Cartie, Carter showed artistic aptitude from childhood, winning prizes at the county and Ohio State fairs before coming to Cleveland in 1923 to study at the Cleveland School of Art under Henry Keller and Paul Travis. With the patronage of Cleveland Museum of Art director William Milliken, he traveled to Capri, Italy in 1927 to study with Hans Hofmann. He supported himself as a student by waiting tables in the Cleveland Museum tearoom, and went on to teach there from 1929 to 1937. In 1935 he entered The Creepers in the museum's May Show, won first prize, and saw it purchased by the Metropolitan Museum of Art, making him the first Ohio artist to have a painting acquired by the Met. He joined the faculty of what is now Carnegie Mellon University in 1938, and was elected to the National Academy of Design as an Associate in 1949 and a full member in 1964. In the 1950s he worked extensively in advertising design for Madison Avenue agencies, with work appearing in Vogue, Fortune, Time, Newsweek, and Business Week. Around 1964 he broke from representational painting, finding in the egg a potent symbol that anchored his work for the rest of his life, building allegorical and neo-Surrealist compositions exploring what one critic described as the nexus between life and death and the transition from earth to spirit. His work is held in the collections of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Modern Art, the Whitney Museum, the Art Institute of Chicago, the Smithsonian American Art Museum, the Corcoran Gallery, and the Cleveland Museum of Art, among many others. Working across oil and watercolor across a career of nearly eight decades, Carter moved from Depression-era American Scene painting to one of the most distinctive bodies of neo-Surrealist imagery in twentieth century American art.